Who we help
Christian health insurance: your 4 options for 2027
Four ways to cover a Christian family, side by side: a faith-based health share, a Marketplace plan, a private plan and a high-deductible core with gap coverage. Health sharing is not insurance. Here is what each one does when a bill arrives.
Faith-based coverage. Straight answers.
The short answer. Most plans sold as "Christian health insurance" are health sharing programs. Members send a monthly share, and the program uses it to help pay other members' eligible medical bills. A health share is not insurance. You have four real options: a faith-based health share, a Marketplace plan, a private plan bought outside the Marketplace, or a high-deductible core plan with gap coverage on top. America First Healthcare is an independent insurance agency, built by conservatives, for conservatives. A licensed advisor compares all four with you on a free 15-minute call, and tells you to keep your current coverage if it already fits.
Open Enrollment for 2027 coverage runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027 in HealthCare.gov states. December 15 is the last day to enroll for coverage that starts January 1 (HealthCare.gov, dates and deadlines). Each health share sets its own enrollment rules. Marketplace plans follow this window.
What "Christian health insurance" means
People search for it in a few ways. They want a plan that fits their faith. They want a lower monthly price. Or they want a community that helps when a hospital bill arrives. Each want points to a different structure, with different rules on price, pre-existing conditions and tax credits. The table puts them side by side.
Your 4 options, side by side
| Option | Is it insurance? | When a bill arrives | Conditions you have today | Premium tax credit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Faith-based health share | No | Sharing is voluntary. If a bill is not shared, you owe it | Not required to cover them | No |
| Marketplace plan | Yes | Pays covered claims under its contract | Must cover them. No plan can charge you more | Yes, if your income qualifies |
| Private plan outside the Marketplace | Yes, but the type varies | Pays the services the policy lists | Underwritten plans can decline you or exclude a condition | No |
| High-deductible core plus gap coverage | Core: yes. Gap: no, it pays a set cash amount | The core pays the bill. The gap helps with the deductible | Depends on the core plan | Only if the core is a Marketplace plan |
Sources: not insurance, no guarantee a claim is paid, and no ACA protections required (NAIC); sharing is voluntary and the member stays responsible for the bill (Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance); pre-existing conditions (HealthCare.gov); the tax credit, available only through the Marketplace (HealthCare.gov). How a core-plus-gap stack is built is in the catastrophic core and gap research note.
Fit check
Health share or a plan? Check your fit in 3 taps
A faith-based health share could fit you
- A health share can fit a household with no ongoing condition that could pay a large bill for a while. It is not insurance.
- Ask for the latest independent audit, the rules for conditions you have today, and what you pay before sharing starts.
What a Christian health share is, and what it is not
A health care sharing ministry is a membership arrangement. Members who hold the same faith pay a monthly share. The program uses it to help pay other members' eligible medical bills under its written guidelines. Some programs send the money into a common fund. Some send it straight to the member who has a bill.
Federal law defines the term in the Affordable Care Act. A "health care sharing ministry" is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit whose members share common religious or ethical beliefs, who keep their membership after a medical condition, that has shared medical expenses without a break since at least December 31, 1999, and that has an annual independent audit made available on request (26 U.S.C. 5000A, Cornell Law School). A newer program may work the same way and still not meet that definition. Ask which one you are joining.
The NAIC, the group of state insurance regulators, says it plainly (NAIC):
- Health care sharing ministries are not insurance and cannot guarantee that a claim gets paid.
- They do not have to follow the ACA's consumer protections, such as covering pre-existing conditions or capping out-of-pocket costs.
- State insurance regulators do not supervise them. 30 states explicitly exempt them from insurance regulation.
- They usually have no provider network, so members may pay full price rather than negotiated rates.
Michigan's insurance department adds that ministries "are not considered health insurance because they do not assume any risk" (Michigan DIFS, January 23, 2024). Some families still choose a health share, with open eyes. The full explainer, with the regulator quotes, is in health sharing ministries: how they work and what members pay.
How health sharing works, step by step
- You join and agree to the program's guidelines. That usually includes a statement of faith and a lifestyle commitment.
- You pay a monthly share. It goes toward other members' bills, not into an account of your own.
- You get care and send in the bill. Many programs treat you as a self-pay patient, so you can ask which providers you may use. Ask what you pay yourself before sharing starts.
- The program checks the bill against its guidelines. The guidelines decide what is eligible. Read the exclusions before you join.
- Eligible amounts are shared. Members' shares pay the bill or pay you back. Nothing obliges anyone to pay.
What families pay each month
Every program sets its own price. Here is what our clients' applications showed, next to the other plan types our advisors placed in the same months. Half of the 1,153 health-sharing applications we submitted from July 1 to October 13, 2026 were $241 a month or less. The middle half ran $145 to $450.
Price alone does not decide the choice. Every monthly price comes with the rules in the table above. The groups in the figure differ, so it is not a like-for-like price test. The Marketplace figure is before any premium tax credit the household received. For prices by state and age, see how much health insurance costs per month.
Who a health share fits, and who should compare a plan first
A health share can fit a household that holds the program's beliefs, has no ongoing condition to manage, and could pay a large bill for a while if sharing is slow or a bill is not eligible. It also fits families who pay for routine care themselves and want help only with a large bill.
Compare a Marketplace plan first if any of these is true:
- Someone on the plan has an ongoing condition or takes a regular prescription. Marketplace plans cannot refuse to pay for a condition you had before coverage started (HealthCare.gov).
- Your income could qualify for a tax credit. It applies when household income is between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level, and only on Marketplace plans (HealthCare.gov).
- You need a guaranteed cap on what you pay. A 2027 Marketplace plan caps your share of covered in-network care at $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family (HealthCare.gov).
Values matter in this choice, and we respect them. Sharing in the needs of fellow believers is a real draw for many Christian families. A licensed advisor can show you the numbers for each option, so the choice is yours and not a guess.
7 questions to ask before you join a health share
Get the answers in writing.
- Are you a health care sharing ministry under 26 U.S.C. 5000A, or a newer sharing program?
- May I see your latest independent audit? The federal definition requires one, made available on request.
- How do you treat conditions I have today? Ask for the waiting period and any dollar limit.
- What do I pay myself before a bill is shared, and is there a yearly or lifetime sharing limit?
- What is not eligible? Ask about maternity, prescriptions, mental health and care outside the United States.
- How long does sharing take, and who pays the provider in the meantime?
- Which beliefs and lifestyle rules do I agree to, and what happens if I break one?
How a licensed advisor helps
On a free review, the advisor:
- Asks about your household, your income, your doctors and your prescriptions.
- Compares the four options side by side, with every cost shown.
- Tells you to keep your current plan if it already fits.
- Helps you apply if you decide to move forward.
The call takes about 15 minutes, by phone, at a time you pick. It costs you nothing. HealthCare.gov notes that agents and brokers are generally paid by the insurance companies whose plans they represent (HealthCare.gov, find local help). You can check any agent's license on the NIPR license lookup. More on how advisors work is on talk to a licensed health insurance advisor near you.
When you can enroll
Marketplace plans have a window. In HealthCare.gov states, Open Enrollment for 2027 coverage runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, and December 15 is the last day to enroll for coverage that starts January 1 (HealthCare.gov, dates and deadlines). States that run their own exchange set their own dates. Every state is in Open Enrollment 2027 dates by state. After January 15 you need a qualifying life event, explained in missed Open Enrollment? Special Enrollment Periods explained. Plan rules and availability also differ by state. Start from health insurance by state.
For the other coverage choices a conservative household weighs, see conservative health insurance: your 4 real options. For the wider picture outside the ACA, read non-ACA health insurance: your 4 options.
FAQ
Is there Christian health insurance?
Most plans sold under that name are health sharing programs, which are not insurance. The NAIC says they cannot guarantee that a claim gets paid and do not have to follow the ACA's protections. If you want coverage that is insurance, a Marketplace plan or a private plan is the route. America First Healthcare is an independent insurance agency, not an insurance company. Plans are offered and underwritten by third-party carriers.
Is a Christian health share the same as health insurance?
No. The NAIC says health care sharing ministries are not insurance and are not legally required to share funds with members. Michigan's insurance department says they do not assume any risk. Some families still choose one. Read the program's guidelines before you join.
What are Christian health insurance alternatives?
The four options in this guide: a faith-based health share, a Marketplace plan, a private plan outside the Marketplace, and a high-deductible core plan with gap coverage. Each one treats a bill, a condition you have and a tax credit differently. The table at the top of this page compares them.
Does a health share cover pre-existing conditions?
It does not have to. Michigan's insurance department says ministries do not have to cover pre-existing conditions. Each program sets its own rules, so ask for them in writing. Every Marketplace plan must cover pre-existing conditions.
Can I use the premium tax credit on a health share or a private plan?
No. HealthCare.gov says the premium tax credit is available only through the Marketplace.
Can I choose my own doctor with a health share?
Many programs treat you as a self-pay patient, so you may be able to see the provider you choose. The NAIC notes they usually have no provider network, so members may pay full price rather than negotiated rates. Ask each program how it works before you join.
Does a health share cost less than insurance?
Not always. Half of the 1,153 health-sharing applications our advisors submitted from July 1 to October 13, 2026 were $241 a month or less, and half of the 56 Marketplace applications were $161 a month or less before any tax credit. The groups differ, so this is not a like-for-like test. Compare the price and the rules together for your household.
What if I already have a plan I like?
Then the advisor tells you to keep it. The free review compares what you have with what else is available, and keeping your current plan is one of the answers.
References
- Not all products are health insurance, NAIC. Published November 8, 2022, last modified November 11, 2024. Checked November 13, 2026.
- 26 U.S.C. 5000A, Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute.
- Healthcare Sharing Ministries, Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance.
- DIFS Reminds Consumers That Health Care Sharing Ministries Are Not Health Insurance, Michigan DIFS, January 23, 2024.
- Coverage for pre-existing conditions, HealthCare.gov.
- Premium tax credit and out-of-pocket maximum/limit, HealthCare.gov glossary.
- Dates and deadlines, HealthCare.gov.
- America First Healthcare sales records: 2,582 priced health applications submitted July 1 to October 13, 2026, read October 14, 2026 (aggregates only; method in how much health insurance costs per month).
Availability by state
Plan availability and rules vary by state. Tell us your state and a licensed advisor will walk through what is actually available there.